What I’m Looking for in a Church … I Think.
Well, I’ve been to church the last two Sundays, which has at least gotten a couple of my friends off my case.
And honestly, it’s been good both times. Of course, I used an easy thing: a preacher who is very, very familiar to me heads the church I’ve attended. He was my grandparents’ pastor when I was a kid, the only pastor from those days I can remember holding my attention. [My childhood pastor is a great man, but his preaching skills rank last in his overall pastoral toolset. That's fine, because he excels at the rest of it.] Pastor Jerry is far, far funnier now that I’m old enough to get all of his jokes and can now follow his theology.
That said, two Sunday mornings is the extent of my interaction with that church. Sure, I know a couple of the people in the choir—they used to be in the choir at one of my old churches here in town—but otherwise, well, that’s been it, other than pleasantries exchanged during passing of the peace. [Well, and the one choir member who all but chased me down the hall to hug me as I left on Sunday. Heh.]
So I’ve been asking myself, now that I’m back actively looking, “What am I looking for?”
- I have to believe in the preaching coming from the pulpit. United Methodism is as prone to the foibles of modern American Christianity as any other denomination I’m likely to attend [I mean, my PCA brothers don't buy into a lot of the claptrap out there, but, um, I'm a zero-point Calvinist]. The surest way to turn me off from your pulpit is to be basing your preaching around any book besides The Holy Bible. I mean, Rick Warren is a well-meaning fellow and all, but …
- Traditional worship, including a competent choir, is something that’s important to me. Honestly, that’s something holding me up from thinking the place I’ve visited the last two weeks is going to work out: their quite-solid pianist has to buttress the choir [as, I think, their lone tenor], leaving them to sing along to … taped accompaniment. Can you hear my teeth grinding, y’all? [This is to say nothing of the fact that I would be a four-sigma outlier in terms of ages of the choir members.]
- Missional focus. I don’t think a church has to be doing Huge Things for Jesus, but I do think that we have to be actively showing our community love and care for our fellow men. Church cannot be like the lodge down the road, huddled close together in their clubhouse and telling each other it’ll be all right.
What else do you look for when you look for a church? What do you think I should be looking for, friends of mine who want me to find a church? [Remember, you're trying to help me find a church, so suggesting I look for something that's not compatible with where I'm at is probably a big bucket o' FAIL.]