Freakonomics

[This entry starts my Booklogging category. If you're interested, see why I'm booklogging.]

Freakonomics : A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything

So, I finally got around to reading Freakonomics, which makes me a lame Weblogger or something. I found it to be interesting, a nice thumbnail sketch of using statistical analyses to look at the world in interesting ways. A lot of the stuff that Leavitt argues for in the book is the same kind of thing I’ve been reading over the years with the folks who do sabermetrics—taking the data, looking for trends, seeking correlations, and possibly finding causalities.

Doing it from an economist’s point of view, however, widens the scope of the investigation. The things that Leavitt, his colleagues, and others he finds interesting study are really … out there. But they’re pretty doggone cool.

The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference One thing that I found interesting, however, is how Leavitt’s regression analysis that found a correlation between abortion becoming legal with Roe v. Wade and a nationwide drop in crime pretty much kicks the leg out from under the anecdotal argument that Malcom Gladwell made in The Tipping Point about what worked in drawing down crime in New York City. Considering how much the blogosphere talks about both Freakonomics and The Tipping Point, you’d think I’d've run across someone remarking this before. [However, I've probably missed every reference to this contradiction. Oh well. In this case, I'm writing for my limited audience. :) ]

Anyhow, if you like unconventional thinking and having your preconceptions challenged a bit—or in watching others’ preconceptions shaken—it’s a good little read. It was great for a Saturday afternoon in Florida.

Posted August 24th, 2005 in Booklogging by Geof F. Morris.

2 comments:

  1. Dad:

    Beware statisticians finding correlation between two things that do not have a logical cause and effect relation.

    I have always said. “Give me enough data and the correct tests to reject outliers, and I will correlate the positions of the plantets to major wars in Europe.”

  2. Artur Krol:

    Actually, the data in both Freakonomics and The Tipping Point does not need to be mutually exclusive.

    Gladwell does mention about a general decrease in crime in the USA, only pointing out to the more intense decrease in NYC.

    And Levitt does mention that the abortion was the main cause – but not the only cause.

Leave a response:

Note: This post is over 4 years old. You may want to check later in this blog to see if there is new information relevant to your comment.

By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution.